Their proposal went wrong when he dropped the ring down a utility grate - but the NYPD found it and is trying to track them down. The only problem: The NYPD is still searching for the couple.
NYPD is expected to release more information later Sunday.
According to the Associated Press, the couple appealed to the police for help after losing the ring, but emergency service officers were unable to locate it. "Our @NYPDSpecialops officers rescued it & would like to return it to the happy couple".
Republican in 'public hanging' video wins Mississippi Senate race
Hyde-Smith's comments prompted deeper dives into her history. 'Mississippians know me and they know my heart, ' she said . A separate video showed her talking about "liberal folks" and making it "just a little more difficult" for them to vote.
It is unclear why he chose to propose atop a subway grate, but love makes you do wild things.
But her partner became so excited at her response he dropped the engagement ring straight down a drain. "Every argument between them will end with "at least I didn't drop the engagement ring down the sewer grate", a twitter user BigJim wrote".
The New York Police Department confirmed on Sunday that it had found the hapless duo.
But a happy ending was coming for what the department called its "almost engaged" couple.